Tag Archives: customer service

Social Media As Customer Service #Fail

Peter Himler, aka The Flack, has a great post today on the gap between how companies should be using social media to enhance customer service, and the reality of their continuing failure to do so.

Himler picks up a thread from TechCrunch co-editors Erick Schonfeld and Paul Carr took American Airlines to the cyber woodshed for issuing Tweets promising to resolve a customer service issue and then failing to deliver on the promise.

As I reported a while back, social media works best when marketing and customer service departments are able to share information and resolve complaints in a timely and satisfactory manner.

Few companies have mastered this feat, which is understandable considering the challenges involved in “hearing,” evaluating, routing and resolving every single complaint that hits the Internet. Especially if you’re a corporation the size of American Airlines.

Carr lambastes Corporate America for hiring “19-year-old, disaffected, invent-your-own-job-title millennials” to manage their social media programs, whose mission is to get complainers to take their issues private and out of the public’s view.

Out of sight, out of mind…until an aggressive complainer, whose problem is still not resolved, decides to call out Company X for not only its lousy customer service, but also its failure to make good on the promise to fix the problem.

The time has come for marketing and customer service to divide the labor and share responsibilities for social media. One should focus on promoting the brand and the other should be responsible for responding when the brand fails to live up to the promise in the eyes of an angry customer.

How this would work in a garden variety multi-billion dollar corporation, where different departments are often housed several floors apart, or in different buildings or in different hemispheres, is a major challenge.

Especially when social media responsibilities are deemed unimportant enough to be placed in the hands of someone who could—oh, I don’t know—drop a curse word into the corporate Twitter feed.

Social media can be a powerful tool for marketing and customer service…if you have the guts to make the investment and integrate these important functions through one seamless interface.

Good luck.

Leave a Comment

Filed under Issues Management, Listening, Social Media

Can Marketing and Customer Service Share Social Media Responsibilities?

Thought-provoking article in MediaPost today on how companies plan to use Twitter and Facebook for customer service in the coming year.

According to a Gartner, Inc. report referenced in the story, roughly one in three large companies will begin using their online communities to improve customer service in the coming year (that’s up from a mere five percent in 2010).

Right now, most companies manage their social media presence through their marketing departments, which works pretty well for proactive communication, but few companies have found a way to effectively respond to customer complaints and constructive criticism using social media (after all, marketing is about making promises, not keeping them)

“[Gartner] identified several hurdles slowing the shift to customer care through social sites. Despite the hype surrounding social media as a customer service tool, there is a lack of back-end technology in place to support customer service operations through online social channels. ‘There are a myriad of technology and process issues that arise when you go from ad hoc support to scalable and structured support,’ said Drew Kraus, research vice president at Gartner.

Kraus cites HP and Drugstore.com as two companies that have figured out a way to use social media to improve customer response, but they are on a very short list.

In recent years, we’ve all been working hard to integrate sales and marketing to ensure that the promise (marketing) is living up to the customer’s expectations and serving her needs (sales).

We now need to incorporate customer service into the mix. I think that’s what Philip Kotler et al. are talking about in their book Marketing 3.0. Randall Ringer has a nice viewpoint that you can read HERE.

Leave a Comment

Filed under Return On Investment, Social Media

Stellar Customer Service From Trapp & Co.

For Valentine’s Day I decided to be original and purchase some flowers for my wife.

I contacted a local florist, Trapp & Co., via its Website and requested a suitable bouquet. Within minutes, one of their designers phoned to ask a few questions about what I wanted and what I expected to pay.

Friday afternoon, I dropped by the store to pick up the arrangement, which  surpassed my expectations. My wife loved the flowers.

And then things went south.

By Sunday, the hydrangeas had imploded and the lilies and roses in the arrangement were clearly past their prime.

At 8:44 this morning, I sent the following e-mail to Trapp under the subject line “Constructive Criticism”:

First the good news:

This past Friday, I picked up an arrangement for my wife for Valentine’s Day, and must say that the flowers were more beautiful than I expected. With minimal input from me, your designer assembled a bouquet that was absolutely stunning and my wife (and daughter) loved it.

Now the bad news:

I expect flowers to stay fresh for longer than 72 hours, and certainly don’t expect them to wilt within 48. I’ve attached a photo of one of the hydrangeas (taken this morning) to illustrate my point.

I realize that the laws of supply and demand are not necessarily in the buyer’s favor around Valentine’s Day, but I certainly expect better from Trapp & Co.

Just thought you should know.

Respectfully,

BP

At 8:53 a.m. (nine minutes after I sent my e-mail), I received a call from Trapp expressing their apologies and offering to deliver a replacement bouquet. Wow!

Considering today is Valentine’s Day, the busiest day of the year for florists, I was floored that they responded so quickly and with such a generous offer to make things right.

Good for you, Trapp. You have a customer for life.

Leave a Comment

Filed under Issues Management, Listening

Customer Service in the Trenches

Sue Shellenbarger’s column in yesterday’s Wall Street Journal offers some interesting data on the challenges facing our brave men and women at customer service centers across America.

According to a 20007 survey of more than 1,000 consumers conducted by Customer Care Measurement & Consulting of Alexandria Va., “70 percent of customers who have problems with a product or service are in a rage by the time they talk with customer-service workers; 24 percent yell, eight percent threaten to sue, and five percent start cursing.”

And that was back in ’07, when the economy was still fairly robust. Imagine what it’s like today when one in ten workers is out of a job and our nation is angrier than ever.

One can reasonably assume that this fever pitch is at least partially attributable to the piped-in muzak and assurances that “your call is very important to us” that one must endure for eternity while waiting to speak to an actual person.

Among the stats from the Customer Care Measurement & Consulting survey that I find most interesting:

While only one in four consumers stated their reason for calling was to secure financial compensation related to their complaint and a little over half (57 percent) demanded their money back, nearly three out of four (72 percent) called merely to express their anger and tell their side of the story.

Seventy percent wanted an apology and 69 percent wanted a “thank you for your business.”

In short, they wanted someone to listen to and appreciate them. (Don’t we all?)

And that’s tough work. According to the story, turnover at customer service centers ranges from 25 to 300 percent per year. Maybe that’s why companies today do such a poor job of serving their customers.

It’s tough work. It’s expensive. It’s a pain in the ass.

But it’s also something your customers value, and it’s something that most consumers will reward in the long run.

Are you committed?

Leave a Comment

Filed under Listening