Tag Archives: FCC

Who Makes the Rules When the Public Airwaves Are Used for Profit?

I heart FCC Commissioner Michael Copps, who was quoted Wednesday in a Los Angeles Times blog post on the state of journalism in the USA. His take:

“American media is not ‘producing the body of news and information that democracy needs to conduct its civic dialogue,’ Copps said in an interview with the BBC’s Katty Kay. That trend, he added, has to be reversed or ‘we are going to be pretty close to denying our citizens the essential news and information that they need to have in order to make intelligent decisions about the future direction of their country’.”

Copps spoke Thursday at Columbia University in New York, delivering an address entitled, “Getting Media Right: A Call to Action.” You can click HERE to get links to a live broadcast of the address, along with a link to the Katty Kay BBC interview and a related panel discussion. You can also follow coverage using the #cjcopps hashtag.

Copps said that the FCC shares the blame, enabling media consolidation to reduce public access to a diversity of opinions and straight reporting of issues that affect everyday Americans. Additionally, he calls for a more stringent licensing renewal process for local television stations:

Copps wants stations to commit to covering more debates and issues-oriented programming during election years. He also wants stations to be more in touch with the communities they serve.

A position that elicited this response from one reader of the LA Times blog:

“Deregulation” is merely the battle cry of meddling bureaucrats like Mr. Copps. In this case, an FCC commissioner desires to anoint himself judge and jury on what is “proper television news.” Placing the government’s seal of approval on news programming as Mr. Copps suggests is a very slippery slope that leads in only one direction – propaganda a la George Orwell’s Ministry of Truth and the Two Minutes Hate.

Mr. Copps, how well broadcast journalists and their news organizations are doing their jobs is quite frankly none of your damned business. Have you ever heard of the First Amendment? It couldn’t be more clear on this subject. It says that if you’re a bureaucrat whose legal authority derives from Congressional action, as is the case with the FCC, then you are cordially invited to BUTT OUT.

Posted by: Sid Vicious | December 02, 2010 at 08:54 AM

Nice of Mr. Vicious to come back from the grave and offer his opinion, don’t you think?

But therein lies the rub. Whom should have the right to decide what’s in the public’s best interest? And how is it that the public’s airwaves are being used by for-profit enterprises to deliver those messages in the first place?

I understand that the media companies pay handsomely for the licenses that allow them to broadcast, but where does the proper balance between profit motive and public interest exist…and who decides?

Anyone?

Leave a Comment

Filed under Journalism

The Vast Conspiracy Against the Truth

Two items of note this week. The first is the whole Shirley Sherrod scandal, profiled here in a piece on The Huffington Post. The second is this op-ed from Fred Barnes in today’s Wall Street Journal.

Shirley Sherrod, until this week anyway, worked for the USDA administering government assistance to farmers in Georgia. Recently, a conservative blogger posted a snippet of video in which Ms. Sherrod appears to be disparaging whites and suggesting that she intentionally withheld assistance to white farmers based on their race, setting off a media firestorm which led to her being fired. As new facts arose, journalists and political commentators on the left railed against Fox News and others for fanning the flames without presenting all of the facts in the case.  (The Huffington piece listed above includes links to YouTube videos of Ms. Sherrod’s speech in its entirety, as well as the widely circulated  clip that led to her dismissal from the USDA.)

Today, Barnes picks up on a story first reported by Tucker Carlson’s Daily Caller back in June: that a listserv called JournoList includes a thread of messages in which liberal journalists discuss the possibility of conspiring to label opponents of then-Presidential candidate Obama as racists and to deflect news of Obama’s connections to Chicago preacher Rev. Jeremiah Wright.

So one could argue that journalists on both the right and left are having a field day catering to their audiences and feeding America’s “us vs. them” anger. (I can distinctly remember when “us” was Americans and “them” was the terrorists, but I digress.)

In this environment, how can the average person believe anything she sees, reads or hears?

But wait. It gets worse.

With all the bickering and half-truthing back-and-forth, our government has decided to weigh in.

As Jeffrey Folks reported recently:

“Discussions underway at the Federal Trade Commission and the Federal Communications Commission point toward a dangerous new effort to regulate what Americans read and hear. The takeover under discussion would apply across the board to print media, radio and television, and the internet. The result of proposed regulations would be nothing less than an end to free speech in America.”

You can read a copy of the FTC’s “staff discussion” HERE. But the long and the short of it is that our government (who knows what’s best for us all…sarcasm intended…is seeking ways to introduce “balance” and “fairness” in the news.)

All of this reminds of me of when my brother and I used to fight as kids and my Dad would threaten to beat us both if we didn’t knock it off.

At the end of the day, you still have two crying kids and a Mom with a headache.

What does this mean for those of us seeking to get our messages into the marketplace in a meaningful, credible way?

  1. Don’t trust the news media to get it right.
  2. Don’t trust the government to make it better.
  3. Make sure you tell your own story, tell it well and make your story readily available.
  4. Then connect your news and information directly to the people who matter through your social networks.

Leave a Comment

Filed under Uncategorized